Lawyer argues staggered Council elections, new district maps deny thousands the right to vote

An Austin lawyer has sued City Council members over what he says is the denial of voting rights to tens of thousands of residents.

Bill Aleshire filed the lawsuit in a Travis County district court Tuesday on behalf of a dozen Austin residents. He argues that nearly 24,000 people who were moved into new Council districts as part of the city’s recent redistricting efforts are being denied their right to elect a local representative.

“They were moved from a Council district that had been on their ballot to one that has never been and won’t be for two more years,” he told KUT. “In a representative democracy it is not the government that designates and tells people who their representative will be. The voters get to choose.”

Austin staggers its Council elections as part of a measure approved by voters in 2012. Representatives for half the city’s Council districts are on the ballot every two years, with Council members serving four-year terms.

But when a group of volunteers redrew the Council district maps last year – something the city does every 10 years based on new demographic data from the census – some residents found themselves in new districts being represented by people they didn’t vote for.

Aleshire lists a dozen of these residents as plaintiffs. One of them, Carolyn Anderson, was previously in Council District 1, which is represented by Natasha Harper-Madison. Because of redistricting, Anderson now lives in District 4.

A special election was held this year after Greg Casar announced he was leaving Council to run for Congress. The city used the old maps to determine who was eligible to vote in the election, so Anderson did not get a say in who would represent her on Council.

Chito Vela, who won the race, won’t be up for reelection until 2024.

“(Anderson) will have gone six years without having a chance to vote on who represents her on the Austin City Council,” Aleshire said.

Aleshire sued Austin’s 10 Council members and the mayor because they have the power to call elections. If his lawsuit is successful, Vela would have to run again this November – nearly eight months after his first campaign.

Council Member Leslie Pool said through a spokesperson she would not comment on the lawsuit. Council members Mackenzie Kelly, Vanessa Fuentes, Chito Vela and Alison Alter either did not respond to an inquiry from KUT or said they needed to read the lawsuit.

This story was produced as part of the Austin Monitor’s reporting partnership with KUT.

The Austin Monitor’s work is made possible by donations from the community. Though our reporting covers donors from time to time, we are careful to keep business and editorial efforts separate while maintaining transparency. A complete list of donors is available here, and our code of ethics is explained here.